Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Social Revolution Part 4: Fulfillment

Hello Readers,

Now, talking about fulfillment might lead one to believe that this is going to be a very individualistic post. However, the idea of fulfillment is extremely important if we're going to talk about transforming society. Also, fulfillment is something that can give life to the community or destroy it based on how one interprets what it means to be fulfilled. Therefore, we have to build a definition of fulfillment that keeps in mind the common good of the community while meeting individual people's legitimate needs.

To start building a definition of fulfillment, we need to engage the longing of people. An easy way to think about longing is to look at what people complain about most. Lounging about my environment the most common things I hear people complain about are about work, or about other people that are different/are causing problems. Therefore, this anecdotal example shows two enemies to having fulfillment in one's life: difference and stress. While there are many other problems to finding fulfillment, I want to focus on these two pieces to narrow our focus to something common in different populations.

Stress hinders fulfillment because it hinders people's ability to do the things they really enjoy. Some workload is because of the job itself, because every job has deadlines and things to meet so that productivity can occur. However, there is also stress people experience working from simply not enjoying the work they are doing. Since money and the economy is important to survival, people need to work to make their ends meet. Therefore, some people are in jobs that do not fulfill them. This leads to anxieties and lost hopes as people do not fulfill dreams they once had. These build as depressants and many people cope in different ways. When people do work they find unfulfilling, work loses its integration with the rest of people's lives, and as such, work is always seen as a burden, and everything else that goes on is more fun.

In some sense, this explains the life of a college student for many of them. College students work all week on homework, classes, student employment, activities, and stuff, and by Friday, students are exhausted. In the life of a student, this not a 9-5 task either. Classes & activities and stuff can go from 8am-midnight or later when thinking about homework. By Friday, students want care and anything else besides work, so they resort to various escapist activities from real life. Of course a similar model applies to people working dead end jobs. People work their jobs and then go home to do anything else (drink, do drugs, play D & D, etc.) However, this lack of integration cannot sustain people forever because it is built in a reality that is not real.

To continue to have a separation between pleasureable work and pleasureable play makes people feel broken from themselves. Work needs to get done, but we should do our best to be in positions where we can enjoy the work we do and feel like it serves the world in some way. If we can be drawn to deeper relationship and more connectivity with ourselves and others, then we can find more fulfillment in work, which in itself, leads to less stress.

The second thing that I want to discuss about hindrances to fulfillment is about difference. When we are in different situations, where there is a lot of change, or simply an existence different than what we are used to, it causes stress. A fear of difference can hinder fulfillment because it keeps people from trying all the crazy things they never dreamed of trying. Also, this fear of difference and standing out is engrained in our societal norms on many levels. Structures, organizations, and people in power all like the status quo, no matter how much suffering it may do to the majority of people. In these models, the elite also try to find ways to justify the status quo in saying that it serves a majority of the people, that these differences we perceive are inherent in nature and as such our societal/religious structures are appropriate for our world. And while I want to retain religious and civil structure as it is another means to serve the common good, we need to enable people to stand on their own and serve the common good and be themselves.

It's important to be oneself as one will never be happy unless she is herself. And if this means she feels the need to speak or act against important structural issues or problems in society, then she should speak and be enabled to speak. While we might not agree with everyone's formulas for making the world a better place, we need to enable people to be different so everyone can use his different gifts/charisms to serve the world. A fear of difference keeps us from each other and keeps us from being fulfilled, so the solution is to gradually build one's characters as one that accepts difference. How we start to accept difference is to realize that we are all different ourselves, and as such, "I" should act like a different person. Without standing on our two feet, we will never inspire the change we want to see in society, and we will not be able to lead others to find more fulfillment.

So where do we start? We have to start by asking the questions that inspire people to think about why they are doing what they are doing, and are people being fulfilled by what they are doing? The Why Do You Do What You Do campaign is an example of an organized campaign that is provoking some thought. To be really revolutionary, and really inspire change, as individuals, we need to do this for the people around us. Anyone, anywhere, can be a guide by listening and being willing to meet the other where she is at. We can ask the hard questions, and wait for the answers. Our mutual journeying as a people requires that we seek the betterment of the other, because we are responsible for the other that we perceive in our being-present-in-the-world. (Yes, I'm borrowing this idea from Heidegger. :) ). Part of being responsible for the other is helping the other be truly fulfilled and being a sacramental sign of that fulfillment, through various forms of love and care.

Aristocrates

Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Social Revolution Part 3: On Gratitude

Hello readers,

Today there is a simple message which has many potential facets, but in the end stems down to one thing. Our society will only change if we are all more grateful from the gifts we receive from others (human and nonhuman.) Gratitude is defined as appreciating and being thankful for the gifts of the other.

The reason gratitude is necessary for change is because gratitude makes us more aware of our mutual relationship with all things. Thus, gratitude is a necessity for solidarity. Without gratitude, we are unable to connect to others on the deepest level as people remain at the level of appearances.

A deep level of connection with others though is really hard. Two main things hinder gratitude: fear, and our place of status. We're afraid of being grateful because it means three things: a) we can lose the gifts others give us, b) we can fear having responsibility for the other by building a desire to care, and c) we may not like the gift the other gives us. Also, we risk our status by being grateful, because our titles and labels for ourselves go away in relationships where we seek gratitude. What remains in these relationships is a mutual gift sharing between the people invovled in a particular relationship.

Finally, tips for building gratitude in relationships. First, get into activities where role reversal is encouraged. The idea here is to be in relationships where there is a mutual exchange of experience and there is not one person who is the teacher and one person who is the learner. (Note: this is a temptation in a lot of my relationships). Second, we have to learn to appreciate the gifts distant and different others can give to our experience for them being themselves. This will enable us to open up to others and help us love God and neighbor because we engage others where they are at.

Aristocrates

Sunday, October 9, 2011

A Devil's Plot: How to Infest a Structure and Take the People

Note: While the ideas in this piece are my own, the style I'm utilizing is borrowed from C.S. Lewis' The Screwtape Letters.

Outline: Step 1, Take advantage of external circumstances.

Seraphi: Incubus, come here.
Incubus: ehh... what is now Seraphi?
Seraphi: You have a new assignment, you need to work to destroy the church and bring all their souls to me, including the soul of the church.
Incubus: But Seraphi, that's hard, I don't like this idea. Can't I just take one soul and make it extra pure and dark, and dead for you?
Seraphi: No, no, no, it's the right time, you destroy the whole structure of the earthly church from within, (of course we can never actually deal with the eschatological church, but that's a battle for Satan to deal with.)
Incubus: Why is this the right time?
Seraphi: Because there's a sex abuse crisis going on in the church, and we can attack the souls of people in the church, and then that will corrupt the people outside the church, and at the same time we can attack the people outside the church with different demons as well.
Incubus: And you want me to attack the structure right?
Seraphi: Yep, attacking the structure, and the hierarchs of the structure is something you can do very well, plus since sex is part (not all, but of course she won't know that until she sees the situation) of the problem, it's perfectly appropriate that an Incubus attacks. (hehehe)
Incubus: Alright then, off I go, to deal with an attack on a structure at the right time.



Step 2, Make religious structure overvalue one thing and ignore the greater part of the common good.

Incubus: Seraphi!!! What are you thinking giving me this assignment? This problem has nothing to do with sex at all. All the people are complaining about power and stuff in the structure, and the priests that are having sex and doing stuff like this to children don't care about the sex either. They are getting away with the situation because they can. How am I supposed to make this worse? :(
Seraphi: Incubus, you're so impatient!! Don't you see that sex is the key to making this worse, even though the problem is not sex in itself.
Incubus: How do I make this worse? I mean look at the people, they already hate the Church and are having avid protests against teaching and authority.
Seraphi: You realize how insignificant of a problem this is in the long run don't you. (Especially because the Almighty has weird ways of engaging salvation, for as much as the Church talks about the Almighty being the only way, the Almighty has certainly taken a lot of souls in unexpected ways.) The real problem is when the structure and faith itself emanates evil and counteracts its own work. People disagreeing with the hierarchy really is a non-issue for me. Some of these people are more dangerous as they heal the brokenness of others and make the Almighty, church, and religion a safehaven. What really causes brokenness is if we can cause a hyper-reaction to something in culture, in this case the sex abuse crisis. (Of course the situation is really more complicated than just this simple hyper-reaction, but she can't really know that yet, she has to let experience hit her in the face. More importantly, the range of factors for any issue is infinite, but the souls of the people fighting really aren't important and for the most part aren't that dark to where I can allure them into darkness. The hierarchs, The hierarchs are more important right now.
Incubus: So basically, you want sex to be the hyper-reaction.
Seraphi: Hehehe, yes, yes, if sex is the hyper-reaction in the Church it will cause more issues of power (especially since we can convince the hierarchs to ignore the mystical connection in sexual practice that binds people together. Yes, people can screw up sex and hurt each other, but this bonding thing even outside of "marriage" connects people and communities, and then the Almighty comes and I can't deal with it all. That stupid line, "Where two or three are gathered, there am I in their midst (Mt)" sadly that's true even in sexual practice. The Almighty comes and connects people together with an opening of hearts. That's the key to a complete takeover of souls is to make people not connect with each other in any real way... Hooking up only does so much to corrupt the participants invovled because there's still that desire for real connectivity, and it only corrupts for so long too.)
Incubus: Seraphi, are you in your own head again?
Seraphi: Shut up Incubus, I'm plotting. But yes, use sex as a means to cause a hyper-reaction and work to build a message of faith that destroys community building. If we can do that, we're well on our way to capturing many people and making them wallow in our darkness.
Incubus: But how do I do that?
Seraphi: Make something about sex the perceived.... ah ha, yes connect all forms of sexual practice (in and out of marriage) connected to abortion in some way. If you can do that you demonize connectivity and this "unitive" end of marriage. Demonizing connectivity on a physical level will destroy it on deeper levels too. We can use this to disconnect the people and harm the common good.
Incubus: Seraphi has all the best ideas! :) Hehehehe We'll win
Seraphi: (ehh your enthusiasm is sickening, especially because satan hasn't found a way to deal with the eschatological church, all we can really deal with is the problems of the earthly church, and we've been doing this since the beginning of time. hmm...)





Step 3, Distract people with a non-issue, yet have authority abuse their power to shove something down a person's throat harming the common good more

Incubus: Seraphi!!! Argh! It was working so well. I got the hierarchs to care only about sexual practice and spreading that faith, connect everything in sexual teaching to not having an abortion, bringing this practice to the younger people, which harmed their vulnerability and relationships which was a fun effect, but now they're all bitching and complaining about Mass and translations, and abuses of authority. Waaaa!!! :'(
Seraphi: Incubus, you're insolent and you never stop. Don't you see how good this situation is for our purposes?
Incubus: Does Seraphi have another idea? :)
Seraphi: Of course I do, but step 1 of this idea is you have to prevent people from binding together against this new Mass translation.
Incubus: So, basically make them feel like there's nothing they can do and they're alone?
Seraphi: haha, you're actually learning, good work. But we can do a lot more with this plan. We can use this translation to make people believe all of their relationships will be like this one. In other words, if we can promote an irresponsible use of authority and overblow this problem, then we can extrapolate and cause people to lose hope in all their relationships.
Incubus: But isn't an irrresponsible use of authority something people actually should care about because bad leadership harms the common good. People seem to have this natural instinct to fight against bad leadership when possible.
Seraphi: Yes, but we can make people think all of their relationships are tyranny, including their relationship with the Almighty, simply based on how the hierarchs are acting. If the hierarchs shove something down people's throats (like a bad Mass translation, and yes this is God awful but we might as well use it for chaos), then people see this as symbolic of all of their relationships, because they are supposed to trust the clergy in their opinion. Since we've seen with the sex abuse crisis and now this Mass translation that they can't we're making the people lost in themselves. As long as we prevent the lights from speaking and building bridges, then our plan will be successful.
Incubus: You come up with all the best ideas Seraphi :).
Seraphi: (Hehehee, this is working perfectly. I'm so glad I thought of all these ideas, granted I've just borrowed them from the history of demons in different crises, like the Reformation for example, but so much of religious, salvation, and demonic history stems from power and sex. The worst part is, I still have yet to really deal with sex as a major demonic component. The hierarchs are the only real thing I've come up with to deal with this component because their talking against sex and touch and deep relationships leaves people alone and prevents the "where two or three are gathered")
Incubus: You're always stuck in your head Seraphi, you need to spend more time with me, and we can be wicked and spread misery together, isn't that what being together is all about for us demons. Spreading mischief and mayhem and creating a bad sense of adventure.




Step 4, Keep up the issues of sexuality and the new Mass translation as issues which cause people to look away from the common good, instead of at it. Subtle but important.

Seraphi: Incubus, I see you've come back, how's things on the surface.
Incubus: Seraphi, we have a problem, there are people starting to look toward the common good and build community and responding to our plan to make the hierarchs care only about sex and authority.
Seraphi: The Almighty! Of course the Almighty figured out what I was doing. (I guess this is part of that stupid eschatological Church thing with Jesus and the Spirit and whatnot.) Alright, for now we have to keep these issues of sexuality and the new Mass translation as signs of isolation up in certain sectors. We need to influence the hierarchs voices to be louder, more annoying, and more about dividing the community between lay and cleric. The more division the better, this will buy us more time.
Incubus: okay, so more time, but how do we get people to look away from the common good, these lights seem to be doing a good job of awakening people to the common good.
Seraphi: We have to discourage the lights by isolating them more, make them seem like pariahs, and invoke more demonic presence on them. If you can do that, the crowds will think they are crazy, and then we can attack the isolated people. But for you, first things first, we have to keep attacking the hierarchs and create a stronger defensive reaction. Pro-life = anti-abortion was a very effective mentality and we need to keep attacking here. We can overlook some of the younger people now, we have a few years before they see what's going on (stupid postmodern Europeans being so open to God and making sense. Caring and sharing and gift, argh!!! All these things strengthen relationships and open people to others, and these young people get this so well and) Incubus what is it?
Incubus: Seraphi, we have to attack now, there's more stronger light coming our way and we're in danger.
Seraphi: We both have to escape the base and get to the surface and become wolves in sheep's clothing.
Incubus: What do you mean?
Seraphi: We have to look exactly like the structure to continue our infiltration. Hurry before the lights radiate us as well as our base, make your armies invisible and prepare for the next stage of stealth attack. (All this time, we fought so hard to prevent relationship buildling. All the sex, all the authority, all the anti-abortion campaigning, it was all to prevent people from coming together so that we could take them from a place of despair. All I wanted was despair and death so people might have a chance to come here, we have to ignore the stupid Almighty and forgiveness and that kind of thing, but we had a chance to take out everything, argh!!!!!))

Aristocrates

Sunday, September 25, 2011

Social Revolution Part 2: Gossip, Building Up, and Solidarity

Hello Readers,

In order for the world to change, we have to understand the importance of gossip and how much it contributes to a breakdown of society. To do this, we have to engage how societies are built on shame, how gossip binds cliques of people together, and finally how gossip gives us a hated other to build ourselves up. These three things though they feel good in the group setting do not contribute to an overall solidarity that embraces love of neighbor even those neighbors who are distant in any way (age, experience, etc). The end goal of this reflection is to engage the possibility of using language to build up the community and spread good rumors about people, and favorable parts of people's appearance (defined as the symbolic representation of the unseen self, and has physical, mental, and spiritual components.)

To start, we have to examine how societies are built on shame, both religious and political. Shame is a component of society because all societies have mores. Shame occurs when people are judgmental toward others who do not meet certain mores. For example, if someone does not follow a certain rule, such as not mowing your lawn in your boxers on a Thursday, then society will punish the person mowing the lawn by words, shunning, etc. It's important to note that shame while it can happen for laws, it moreso happens because people are different and do not follow unwritten rules of conduct. Examples would include someone who does not fit in a specific gender role set by society. Shame; therefore, is an important part of society for many people, because it tries to build and keep a status quo. However, shame cannot have a part in love, because it does not let people appear and be a mutual interface with each other in a communal experience.

Part of shame is gossip. Societies of people that have a status quo gossip about others who are not in their status quo. If I sit down on a bus and am not talking to anyone, most often I hear some form of gossip. For people in a society (read community), gossip is almost natural, because we either have to talk about the heretics and how they are destroying the world, or we have to talk about that weird stalker kid who looks creepy and might like me. We talk about the other so as to distance ourselves from the other. The other is the hated other who becomes the scapegoat for the clique to build themselves up. In this way, gossip builds community in a clique sense because common people that have a common status quo can spread bad rumors about people not in their clique. However, this is problematic as we don't learn from the other, and are not challenged by the other, if the other is not embraced in our arms, and loved like God loves all. The reason we need a larger community is because cliques break down, once the common theme of gossip is gone, and the community pleasure received from gossip is gone, these cliques break down unless something else happens to expand a friendship. In other words, the clique does not allow for an embrace of the unknown, and without the embrace of the unknown we can never truly love anyone, because we will only love their appearance as it is given before us.

So we see the problem before us. A clique and a status quo form because people like the appearance of a certain way of society and do not want to embrace the unknown. The opposite of this behavior is to have an openness to the other and seek to build up people and work to have solidarity with them. When we build up the other we are praising their appearance for the joy it brings us and the community. Positive talk of people's appearance is a good thing because it embraces a symbolic representation of an unknown and lets it flourish. For example, when we praise someone who has a strong appearance in caring or leadership, we're praising not just that role that a particular self/person (self keeps the mysterious quality I'm looking for in talking about this topic.) has in my life, but how that appearance extends into other relationships. In this way, praise offers gratitude to the other and elevates the other to inspire more service and love. Praise also puts us in solidarity with others because we are elevating others and embracing the unknown self. This allows our love of others to grow and helps us to grow past the clique and embrace real community as we can only love the unknown, otherwise we become too attached to appearances and our love becomes idolatrous and narcissistic.

In closing, we have to nuance our vision a little bit. There are people that do real harm to the common good, and to protect others from real danger is something we are morally obligated to do. But we have to discern the difference between real harm and existential discomfort. (Of course, these are not mutually exclusive necessarily but there is a difference between someone being weird and someone raping people.) Also, there are people that drive us crazy. Everyone has pet peeves and issues with others. We have to allow for outlets with close friends to help us engage people who drive us crazy. There's a difference between talking to a confidant about people driving you crazy and spreading rumors amongst a whole group of people where there is no expectation of silence. These things being said, our goal in solidarity should be to continue to grow more patient and more loving in the mutual interfacing we experience consistently with the world. When we love more and build up more, I think we'll find that less things drive us crazy, especially as we understand and gain solidarity with the people around us and far away...

Aristocrates.

Monday, September 19, 2011

"The Well and the Gravestone" by the Vespers

"Here lies the heart of me. Buried with an unmarked gravestone. No name just the dates you lived and died and now I want it back.
Always fighting but never seeing the way. Teach me how not to be afraid. (counter-melody: teach me to love again, to love again).
Take me down and let me see, the well that's full of bravery, and baptise me so I'll be free, to do the things I fear.
Always fighting but never seeing the way. Teach me how not to be afraid (counter-melody, teach me to love again, to love again).
Hiding in a filthy hole with a battered, bruised and blistered soul, we will laugh the day I'm whole and I'll finally see why I used to cry. Ooh ooh ooh ooh, ahhh, ahhh, ahhh
Always fighting but never seeing the way. Teach me how not to be afraid. Always fighting but never seeing the way. Teach me how not to be afraid. Once again, once again."

Heart break and loss is something that existentially shakes all people. However, some of the grace in heart break is that it has the potential to liberate people from fear. There is a need for grace in order to find strength to love again. When hearts break and people lose hope, there is a temptation for despair. This song is a great message to keep fighting and embrace the future hope that can come forth in times of suffering. This is a short meditation but I want the song to speak for itself.

Aristocrates

Sunday, September 11, 2011

Social Revolution Part 1: Care, Control, and Flirting

Hello readers,

As today is September 11th I want to take a little bit to give a memorial for those who died on September 11th and since in the ensuing wars that have happened. I pray we learn many things from what happens when fear is utilized and how others are demonized through fear. And sadly, a few bad apples create havoc and fear for everyone. All we can do now is try to grow and seek peace even when people are not peaceable to us.

Control and fear is something I want to talk about today but I want to back up a couple steps and give a brief introduction to what I want to talk about in this entry. I want to explore more about three aspects of human relationships that often create significant tension for people trying to build friendships/relationships. Note: Most of this entry will be dealing with these questions in regards to relationships though the principles suggested can be applied to all relationships in general. Care, control, and flirting is named such because it is three responses people can have in response to people being nice to others. Of course we don't want to oversimplify too much because there are as many responses to others' care and compassion as there are people and situations that arise and people to react to others' behavior. Also, any one behavior can exhibit any level of all three intentions: care, control, and flirting. However, what I want to examine is our human tendency to assume a control or a flirting response in response to someone's kindness. (Minnesota Nice falls under a different category as that is social custom, I also want to limit my search to personal interactions, and while Minnesota Nice does affect social interactions, it does not affect the existential feeling of care, control, or flirting, except inasmuch as Minnesota Nice affects a subconscious. And while it does affect the subconscious a social construction can only do so much to determine behavior, givenness and an individual's BIS (Biological Incentive System) do the rest of the determining and then the rest is left up to individual choice.

So now that some of the nuance is accounted for let's give a scenario. A guy walks up a woman and comments that he likes her dress. The woman has three possible sets of responses that she can give. 1) She can act like he is caring and respond to his care. 2) She can think his comment is an attempt to control her behavior or get her to do something and respond to his control. 3) She can think he is flirting with her and respond in kind by either flirting or keeping him at a safe distance. Anyone have an answer to what the man's comment is? The correct answer is it's a trick question. In order to accurately determine whether he is caring, controlling, or flirting, you have to assess the man's behavior over a long period of time, and even then it may not be completely accurate in assessing whether the man has any one (or possibly a combination) of the three responses. However, in most social situations a comment like this one is going to be taken as one of the latter two responses, even though an honest discernment says it is really hard to tell what exactly the man is up to in this scenario.

Now why would a woman (or we can use a man receiving the same kind of comment) assume either a control or a flirting response? The best answer I've found is that there is a fear of the unknown in relationships because they are out of our control. This includes many different things such as what happens if I think about building a future (e.g. a friendship or relationship with a particular person), what happens if he/she likes me and I don't like her/him back? This fear creates an analysis that happens quickly in response to a given stimulus. And in a quick analysis, it's easier to come up with a control or a flirting response, partially because it's easier to respond to a control or a flirt response, and extremely difficult to respond to a care response, and if it's nuanced and multi-layered, it's even more difficult. And of course, discussing feelings is awkward because in society, men are only taught to have two feelings, and discussing feelings requires a level of vulnerability and trust on the part of both persons, so feelings do not always come to the fore right away, even if subconsciously our BIS is triggering feelings that motivate our actions toward a perceived reward. (e.g. sexual activity with someone we find attractive will trigger an orgasm which is a pleasant feeling.) The lack of discussion about feelings creates a game that forces the other to be vulnerable first as a back and forth game of both people trying to grab control in a relationship.

The game works something like this. Men are taught to build up courage to make "moves" on a particular woman, and the woman so as not to seem too easily obtained plays "hard to get". Now of course, this is not always the case, men can play hard to get and women can make moves as well, but what's listed above is the general tendency for relationship forming. (I also realize that homosexual relationships create a different nuance but some level of this mutual seeking and game-playing exists in forming these relationships as well. And dare I say, even in friendship as well, since we're taught to not appear too needy, even building non-sexual friendships has some level of game theory, even though it looks different (mostly not calling too much, etc.) Game theory goes on for a period of time until both people build a level of trust based on how well each person has played the game. Playing the game well involves giving adrenaline rushes and endorphin highs to the other through encounter, teasing, sparks, whatever you may, namely the sense of being romantic. Or in a non-sexual friendship it mostly occurs when one of the two friends breaks the game by showing brokenness. Showing brokenness changes the rules of the game and breaks the game because the masks of perfection come off, and the person is exposed for the friends to see. Yes, you can hide your self from yourself.

Next, we have to explore why it's advantageous to play a game. We've explored the psychological effect above, but I think there is also a possible biological effect to playing a game with others. I've mentioned BIS which is an incentive system which encourages people to do things which are pleasureable. People move toward those things which are pleasureable, or they move toward things which may lead to greater pleasure later even if there is some pain now. New relationship forming has some level of anxiety. A new person means new circumstances, feelings, and a new person to explore and engage. The unknown creates fun but also creates complications, especially when people trigger unknown buttons which unleash all sorts of uncontrolled feelings. But part of the exploration is the notoreity and adventure of meeting a new person which creates an adrenaline rush. The continued game of vulnerability back and forth also creates good feelings for the participants.

Again, I'm going to use stereotypes here and realize that the opposite can be true depending on circumstance. Say a woman likes being pursued by a man before she dates him. She doesn't like to submit easily to saying yes for a date. So most men back off before asking this particular woman out. She enjoys the conquest of overcoming a "weak" man by getting him to step aside. She gets a happy adrenaline rush by taking control of another person and utilizing emotion and circumstance to her advantage. This is a great feeling for her. The other feeling she enjoys is when a man continues to pursue her and eventually enough magic happens for her to submit sexually to him; however that looks. Biologically she also feels good when a man has given enough pursuit and has continued to "hunt" her. However, she has issues about 2-3 months into the relationship when she notices that he cannot fulfill her any longer. He starts to beat her and starts dating other women looking for more conquests. She wonders why this behavior continues in her relationships.

Though this is stereotyped, it gives some insight into the minefield of dating at college campuses and with young adults in general. Women that like being pursued (of course not all of them) are acting on biological impulse. If a man continues pursuit of a woman, she is going to get a man who is strong and can target prey. His physical aggression will be comforting because she'll feel protected, which in turn leads to an increase in sexual pleasure. The man who goes after a woman who is hard to get also gets a large adrenaline rush from finally capturing his target. (Again, this can and does work in reverse too, I just wanted to use the stereotype that people would be familiar with). In a sense, it's a playing out of primal instinct, if man can hunt and do enough to capture the target (in this scenario the woman), he'll keep the woman happy. However, this is a danger in relying only on a BIS, because the Biological Incentive System tends to be short-sighted, unless an individual has trained his/her goals to be higher. The short-sightedness comes when the woman realizes all she has captured is a man who can hunt and she'll quickly become boring. The man gets bored unless the woman performs or is forced into more extreme sexual positions (handcuffing, beating to inspire orgasm, etc.) (Again, can work in reverse too.) However, eventually the hunt ends, the masks come off and people have to engage their own lives and stories. Sometimes this "hunt" transfers over into a meaningful, compassionate relationship, but oftentimes it doesn't, because it no longer feels good for the participant(s) involved. When that happens, at best all one can have is a mutual break-up, unless it's a hook-up relationship which then presents it's own complications. This inevitably hurts both participants, and it's because both participants chose a game which feels good in the short term instead of caring about the other and asking about feelings in order to build a long-term care. The short term game creates a burst of good feeling, while the long-term build up feels good but it's slow and not necessarily the lose your mind drunk on feeling adreanline, endorphine, alcohol, caffeine, and whatever else goes into enhancing one's short term burst of sentiment.

The other issue with the game is that it makes any sort of care reflex impossible. Since care, control, and flirting look very similar, it's easier to think that someone is wanting to play the game and respond whether one wants to play the game or not. A care reflex is beyond most people's imaginations for two reasons, a) there isn't a whole lot of a care reflex for most people to begin with, and b) a care reflex is extremely nuanced so a person must be capable of nuance and communication in order to engage someone with a care reflex. Care also has to become a habit, which is hard because it can be discouraging to be a caring person, especially when many people assume a caring person's intention is either control or flirting.

Now to nuance this more, sometimes the game is needed for security, because people have been hurt by those who appeared to be caring, or they want some relief after a bad long term friendship/relationship break-up and want some semblance of control in their lives. These psychological needs must be met; however, in order for society to really change, we need to be a people that care less about control, and care more about caring for others. We have to be people that not only recognize the game but also work to do something about it, even if the game is an endemic cultural problem that teaches people to be focused only on short-term sentiment. (Which is another nuance I want to throw in, we all need short term intense sentiment in order to feel good and function. Depression happens when life becomes unstable and people are unable to count on others for support. Short bursts of feeling can keep people feeling and healthy, adrenaline rushes are a good thing, but what I want to argue against is building a relationship philosophy that seeks these rushes as ends in themselves, either in how much we control others or how well we can play games with other people to get them to do what we want.)

So to conclude, I want to leave with a few remarks about how we can build a society of more caring people.

1) Be a caring person. The habits of a caring person will eventually spread in reputation and people will know there is something different about person X. Be that person that asks how others are doing and try hard to remember things going on in different people's lives. Remembering that someone is in a Greek class she likes is something that can be a deeply caring intention (it can also be used in the game so intention is important as well.)

2) Know how your responses can be taken and be patient with others if they mistake or catch certain parts of other intentions. Flirting and control are not necessarily bad things and these intentions may come in certain actions. If you're walking with someone and you grab their arm because a car comes close you're taking control of the other person. Now this is also a caring response, and can be a flirting response that activates a "spark." However, the person is not going to know what one's intention is unless there is a habit of care and time spent with each other (which is another problem is that people don't want to invest time and intention in relationship, but that can be saved for another post/discussion, etc.) So people may react poorly, and it's partly the society we live in, partly the fears of someone being controlled or someone having unwanted feelings, and partly the awkwardness certain situations bring forth because of the unseen givenness of one or both persons. Part of being patient is talking honestly about one's feelings and engage what's going on with each person, in other words having a conversation and meeting/privileging the other where he/she is at.

3) Finally, talk. Talk about what you're feeling and encourage others to do the same. Build a friendship environment where people can be themselves and encourage an ethic of care. And if we take Jesus as an example, in the modern age a lot of his actions could be seen as controlling or flirting. Jesus did heal women and break social custom by actually talking to women (note he had women followers and John 4 where he talks to a Samaritan woman who have been a major social taboo for any Jew.) Jesus kept caring and talked about what society was like and how people engaged either other. In his teaching and healing, He remained open to the other. This openness to the other can only happen if we know our own feelings, especially if they're complicated. If we fear for someone we care about making poor choices, or if we like someone and care about them, these nuances are important to know for both people to think about and engage in friendship/relationship building to build an ethic of care for the common good.

This discussion is far from complete, though I will end it here for now. All I can really say is to try to love like God loves, privileging the other, listening, and caring, and in these actions, different habits will form and people will see difference. Also, we have to know the "signs of the times" and understand how relationships form and think about why are things happening the way they are. When we know our habits and know how society construes relationships, we can work to be the change we want to see. And also, we can't count on religion to help us in a lot of circles, because these same cycles of competition and hunting in relationship building occur, even though they look different and focus on purity and laughter, rather than a "hunt" persae, even though it is a hunt of sorts, because the end goal is the same of having some sort of relationship with the other. All we can really do to start is show why our faith must be about building a real care ethic and act in those ways that show care.

Peace,
Aristocrates

Monday, September 5, 2011

On Nature and Escapism

Hello Readers,

In any world, there are many worlds associated with it. We associate with not only the present world in our daily interaction, but also with the worlds of history and eschatology. It is in these different types of interactions that we learn more about why our world is the way it is. From the past we learn lessons from past worlds about relationship, interaction, and how people lived simpler and harder lives all at the same time. Things we find natural in our environment today are only there because of events/choices in the past that enable people to have the convenience to have what seems natural to us. Plumbing, warm showers, sliced bread, all of these are innovations which have not always been. These conveniences come naturally to us now but are really the result of the hard work, inventions, and environmental gift of many people and ecospheres. The point of this is that our present world with all of its natures takes place because of the events in a past world and its nature. This is a healthy recourse of examining choices and learning from our mistakes to promote the common good.

However, there are potential issues of idolizing a particular time in the past, or a particular world one encounters in fantasy that may have lessons to teach us about love, charity, and mercy, but when idolized and obsessed about people lose sight of the common good in their own world by losing ability to relate to the present world's own nature. We call this phenomenon escapism. Escpaism is common as it is a coping mechanism to deal with problems in the present world, either with the world itself or its nature. Everyone has some level of escapism, as we all have hobbies that bring us to different worlds and realities. In addition, everyone needs a release from the stresses of life. There are a lot of things about the present world and its nature that are problematic as I've discussed on other blog entries. However, the balance becomes when does this escapism either through history or fantasy become unhealthy. When does it harm the common good not to be alert to this present world and its nature?

1) If escapism causes people to lose sight of the common good, then it becomes a problem. In other words, in escapism if people are not attentive to real world concerns for the sake of preserving the fantasy/history world, then escapism is immoral. People in the real world suffer, and needs must be accounted for in some way, if they arise.

2) If escapism actually causes people to harm each other in any way, then it is a problem. Escapism causes people to enter a different world, thus their character allows them to do things they might not otherwise do in the present world and its nature. While Sartre would argue this is people acting in bad faith, that's besides the point here. (Bad faith is when a person acts against their own self by acting in character differently then they would in the present, real world.) The issue at stake is what happens when characters act in ways that harm other people in the other world and how does that affect people's reality in the real world. Of course, some people will argue that we need to be able to have jokes and make fun for escapism's sake, to not be so serious. However, when that fun causes harm to the other, then there is an issue, as that does not just stay in the fantasy/history world, but carries on with people subconsciously. Escapism does not excuse abuse toward others, or our responsibility to be sensitive to the other.

3) The other must retain her privilege in escapism. The present world and its nature is one of encountering the other. We live in a world of interaction. As such, we have responsibility for the things and people with whom we interact. This responsibility takes on many forms and our interaction draws us to others in a variety of ways. Escapism is problematic when the other loses her privilege for the sake of the fantasy world, of a nostalgic rememberance and desire for an ethic that's passed. Of course, history can teach us many ways of privileging the other if one searches hard enough; however, there are many cases where history and fantasy teach us how to privilege our own desire for nostalgia and a semblance of control in our own lives. In an escapist world, we can control the world to make it show what we want. The other does not have much privilege here. In the present world and its nature, we cannot control all of the world to our conforming. We can't build a reality with everything we want all the time. Therefore, the privilege of the other is important to recognize, because then we can honestly engage the world more fully, even when we cannot control it. In losing control, we gain the things which are really important, but we need the skills to engage the present world and its nature, even if we are asking questions of that nature.

And finally, 4) If escapism disables people from being able to converse about the present world and its reality, then it is a major problem. We live in the present world, which has a certain nature, which changes over time and engages different people and interests. All over the world there are different worlds which have different natures due to the culture and influence of the people. All of these present worlds and their natures are interconnected and result in us having one world with one nature, and at the same time many worlds with many natures. The one world, is the world of the now, and while it takes many forms, in the end people are unified by their desire for community and relationship in the present world and its nature. Relationship requires engagement, if people spend their lives in a nostalgic world, desiring for something better, (and this applies to history, fantasy, and eschatology), then people lose sight of the opportunity to love and relate in the now, and people that need love need you and me to love like we would want to be loved. In other words, to be able to give and love like God does, while also realizing our own need for love and fulfillment in our lives. Escapism becomes problematic when it is the end sought after for release from the present world and its nature. Escapism can be fun and an enjoyable time by oneself or with friends; however, it can also draw people away from the present world and its nature so much so that the common good is lost. A failure to dialogue about any concern or action in the present world and its nature is symptomatic of this problem.

Aristocrates

P.S. An abuse of eschatology takes most of these symptoms but there are two important differences. 1) The object of the escapism has not happened yet so a deep apathy toward anything appears in anticipation for a pious eschatology as purveyed by a group/cult, etc. This has the effect of creating a lack of care for anything that happens in the present world and its nature and disables people from really being able to act for the common good as people take in the problems of the world if it offends their piety. 2) and most importantly, an abuse of eschatology creates a climate of judgment and hell, which usually does not coincide with the present world and its nature. To be clear, eschatology is important as it shows how the heavenly world and earthly one connect, relate, and interact. Eschatology enables people to talk about God, charity, and purpose in a deeper way, as it draws all past, present, and future history together. However, eschatology is a problem when it does not privilege the other as part of God's creation, even when we find the actions of the other person sinful, shameful, and something that harms the common good. A real eschatology which does not create escapism shows us how God discloses all people and seeks for us to work for the common good.